Hyperguides

Orthopaedics / Hand & wrist

Thoracic Outlet Syndrome

Sasha Ristic, MD H. Matthew Quitkin, MD Melvin Rosenwasser, MD
Article


Introduction

The thoracic outlet is comprised of the musculoskeletal structures traversed by the nerves and blood vessels to the upper extremity as they enter the arm. Thoracic outlet syndrome is a compressive neurovascular disorder of the upper extremity.

Etiology

There are several potential sites of compression (Slide):

  • Sternocostovertebral space: Bordered by the sternum anteriorly, the spine posteriorly, and the first rib laterally.
  • Interscalene interval: Formed by the anterior and middle scalene muscles and the first rib inferiorly. The subclavian artery and brachial plexus travel through this space, while the subclavian vein passes anterior to it. This is the most commonly described site of compression.
  • Costoclavicular space: Bordered by the clavicle and the first rib.
  • Subcoracoid: Between the pectoralis minor anteriorly and the ribs posteriorly.

Abnormal congenital structures such as cervical ribs, costovertebral ligaments, and fibrous bands have also been implicated as mechanisms, but no unifying cause has been demonstrated. Cervical ribs, found in ,1% of the population, are found more frequently in patients with thoracic outlet syndrome. Most recently, both major traumas (motor vehicle accidents with clavicular fracture) and minor traumas (repetitive microtrauma leading to intrascalene fibrosis) have been proposed as causal factors.



Slide. Bony borders of the thoracic outlet. (Click on the image for large view)

Symptoms

Myriad symptoms are possible depending on the neurovascular structures involved. Neurologic complaints predominate in most patients. A lower plexus constellation involving ulnar innervated muscles is the most common presentation. Patients usually complain of pain and paresthesias around the neck with radiation to the medial aspect of the arm and to the ring and little fingers. Objective signs of sensory loss and diminished strength are often not found. Venous obstruction is rare. Thoracic outlet syndrome presents as edema and cyanosis and can progress to subclavian or axillary vein thrombosis necessitating fibrinolytic treatment. Arterial involvement is even more rare and presents with signs of ischemia. Arterial emboli may in turn lead to distal ulceration. Onset is usually insidious in nature without a definitive causal event. Symptoms are usually exacerbated by upper extremity activities. Most patients learn to modify their activities, limiting the overhead, abducted position of the arm, and the head forward posture that tend to precipitate symptoms.

Diagnosis

In most cases, the diagnosis is not easy to make. The work-up should be tailored toward ruling out other more common causes of upper extremity pain. When making a diagnosis of thoracic outlet syndrome, one should first rule out:

  • Cervical spine disease (cervical radiculopathy is unusual in the C8-T1 distribution)
  • Carpal tunnel syndrome or ulnar neuropathy
  • Rotator cuff or other shoulder pathology (rule out instability)
  • Brachial neuritis
  • Lung tumors (e.g., pancoast)
  • Angina
  • Other supraclavicular fossa pathology

A careful and complete neurovascular exam is of paramount importance. Patients with thoracic outlet syndrome seem to be more susceptible to other peripheral nerve entrapment syndromes. The median and ulnar nerves distally should be evaluated routinely in these patients. Several provocative tests are described in the literature:

  • Adson test: Rotation to the affected side, with cervical extension. Obliteration of the radial pulse with deep inspiration is considered positive.
  • Wright-hyperabduction test: Shoulders are hyperabducted to 180º and the elbows are flexed. The position is held for 3 minutes with rapid opening and closing of the hand. Asymmetric reproduction of symptoms is considered positive.
  • Shoulder bracing position test: Shoulders are held back and downward, narrowing the costoclavicular space.

Unfortunately, these results must be interpreted carefully, because one or all can produce symptoms in completely normal, asymptomatic individuals.

Work-Up

Phase 1: Baseline Studies

  1. Plain radiographs may show bony anomalies, such as cervical ribs or large C7 transverse processes. A chest radiograph is mandatory to evaluate the apices of both lungs for tumors. Shoulder films can show degenerative disease or signs of chronic instability. C-spine films can rule out degenerative disk or facet joint disease.
  2. Routine laboratory tests should always be performed to rule out metabolic causes of peripheral neuropathy, rhuematologic/connective tissue disorders, and/or infection.

Phase 2: Specific Diagnostic Tests

  1. Angiography can be helpful in cases with vascular lesions, but is of little use in the majority of patients who present with only neurologic symptoms.
  2. Nerve conduction velocities and somatosensory evoked potentials have met mixed reviews, although they appear useful at least in diagnosing coexisting peripheral nerve lesions. Machleder reviewed 80 patients and reported a 74% incidence of somatosensory evoked potentials abnormalities. These tests may be more sensitive if the patient is placed in the provocative position.
  3. Magnetic resonance imaging holds promise for evaluating soft tissue and brachial plexus distortion.

These results must be interpreted carefully for one or all can produce symptoms in completely normal, asymptomatic individuals.

Treatment

Alleviation of symptoms through a conservative management protocol is always the primary goal. Conservative Treatment Conservative treatment consists of modification of aggravating activites and a generalized shoulder girdle muscle strengthening program. Approximately 75% of patients will show significant improvement. Those with double crush injuries are less likely to attain relief of their distal nerve compression symptoms.
Surgical Treatment Indications for surgical treatment include:

  • Failure of conservative therapy
  • Intractable pain
  • Significant neurological or vascular deficit

There is no consensus on the best operation or approach. Cervical rib resection, scalenotomy, scalenectomy, first rib resection, fibrous band excision, and claviculectomy have all been described. Results in the literature vary greatly, partly due to the absence of clear diagnostic criteria. First rib resection with or without scalenectomy is currently in favor, with 37% to 92% good-to-excellent results reported across studies. A transaxillary approach provides good exposure of the first rib, but makes scalenectomy or brachial plexus evaluation impossible. The supraclavicular approach affords good visualization of the brachial plexus and scalenes, but offers only incomplete first rib exposure.

Complications

Vascular, nervous, and lymphatic injuries can occur at surgery. The subclavian artery and vein are at risk during the transaxillary approach. The thoracic duct can be injured when operating on the left side and should be ligated if injury is recognized. Nerve and brachial plexus injuries are usually related to traction and are typically transient. Permanent injuries are uncommon complications in the literature, although one series reported a 19% rate of incomplete recovery for brachial plexus injury.

Bibliography

Adson AW. Surgical treatment for symptoms produced by cervical ribs and the scalenus anticus muscle. Surg Gynecol Obstet.1947; 85:687.

Aminoff MJ. Use of somatosensory evoked potentials to evaluate the peripheral nervous system. J Clin Neurophysiol. 1987; 4:135-144.

Carrol RE. The relationship of thoracic outlet syndrome and carpal tunnel syndrome. Clin Orthop Rel Res. 1982; 164:149.

Chapman MW. Operative Orthopaedics. 2nd ed. Philadelphia, Pa: Lippincott; 1993. Falconer MA. Resection of the first rib in costoclavicular compression of the brachial plexus. Lancet. 1962; 1:59.

Mackinnon SE. Double and multiple crush syndromes-double and multiple entrapment neuropathies. Hand Clin. 1992; 8:369-390.

Machleder HI. Moll F, Nuwer M, et al. Somatosensory evoked potentials in the assessment of thoracic outlet syndrome. J Vasc Surg. 1987; 6:177-184. 1992; 8:369-390.

Novak CB, Mackinnon SE. Thoracic outlet syndrome. Orthop Clin North Am. 1996; 27:4. Nelson RM. Anterior approach for excision of the first rib. Ann Thorac Surg. 1970; 9:1.

Ross DB. Transaxillary approach to the first rib to relieve thoracic outlet syndrome. Ann Surg. 1966; 163:354.

Ross DB. New concepts of thoracic outlet syndrome that explain etiology, symptoms, diagnosis and treatment. Vasc Surg. 1979; 13:313-321.

Ross DB. The place for scalenectomy and first rib resection in thoracic outlet syndrome. Surg. 1982; 92:1077.

Urschel HC Jr. Management of the thoracic outlet syndrome. N Engl J Med. 1972; 286:1140-1143.