Introduction
The prevalence of symptomatic lumbosacral disk herniation is relatively small. It is important to differentiate between the reasonably well-defined entity of sciatica resulting from a herniated intervertebral disk and the less well understood diagnosis of low-back pain. Sciatica is defined as pain radiating down the course of one or more of the roots of the sciatic nerve, extending down the nerve to a point below the knee in one or both legs. Sciatica is merely a symptom, not a specific disease or disorder. The history and physical exam are among the most important tools in differentiating this disease process.
Incidence and Epidemiology
A symptomatic herniated disk occurs during the lifetime of approximately 2% of the population. In most cases, sciatica improves spontaneously. When the prevalence of sciatica and the radiculopathy (10% to 25%) is taken into consideration, it is clear that surgical treatment should be entertained for less than 0.5% of the population.
The intervertebral disk ages naturally from nuclear dehydration through a series of inevitable changes. With progressive degeneration, disk material may herniate, causing nerve root compression. Herniation generally occurs between the ages of 30 and 50 years. The exact cause of pain radiating down the leg is controversial. However, it appears that symptomatic lumbar radiculopathy is a result of mechanical contact between the disk and one or more nerve roots or a result of a combination of this contact and yet undetermined biomechanical and vascular factors. Almost 98% of clinically important disk herniations occur at the L5-S1 (most common) or L4-5 levels.
Clinical Features
Symptoms of nerve root encroachment are variable. They depend on the patient's age and medical condition, the degree of root compression, the place on the nerve root or dorsal root ganglion at which the pressure is occurring, and the types of resultant inflammation and/or pathologic changes around and within the nerve root.
The most common neurologic impairments are:
- weakness of ankle and great toe dorsiflexors (L5)
- reduced ankle reflexes (S1)
- sensory deficits in the feet (L5 and S1)
Occasionally, a massive midline disk herniation may compress the entire cauda equina, resulting in bowel or bladder dysfunction, saddle anesthesia and bilateral lower extremity signs.
History and Physical Exam
It is important to obtain a complete history and ascertain whether the patient's chief presenting complaint is low back pain or sciatica. Information about the patient's general health, past medical history, recent febrile illnesses or any recent procedures the patient may have undergone are also important.
Typically, true radiculopathy produces pain radiating below the knee and is associated with numbness or paresthesia following a dermatomal pattern. The pain is often aggravated by coughing, sneezing or a Valsalva maneuver. A careful neurologic exam is essential to identify any subtle motor or sensory deficits.
Nerve root tension signs further suggest the diagnosis. Straight leg raising test is defined as positive if it reproduces the patient's sciatica at less than 60° of leg elevation. Crossed straight leg raising occurs when straight leg raising is performed on the patient's well leg and elicits pain in the leg with sciatica. Crossed straight leg raising is less sensitive, but more specific for lumbar disk herniations, particularly those with a central component. High (L3-L4) disk herniations can be tested with a reverse Lasegue test, which is performed with the patient prone by flexing each knee in turn. This gives rise to pain in the femoral nerve roots which should be aggravated by hip extension. Screening of the hips by testing pain-free range of motion should also be performed.
Diagnosis
Four criteria are often discussed as being necessary in order to diagnose symptomatic lumbosacral disk herniation:
- leg pain that is more prominent than back pain
- a dermatomal pain distribution
- positive nerve tension signs
- imaging studies correlating with neurologic signs
Patients with suspected lumbosacral disk herniation should have motor and sensory exams that elicit objective signs of specific nerve root involvement. If the motor and sensory abnormalities do not conform to the expected nerve root distribution, another diagnosis should be considered. In the absence of any significant or progressive neurological deficits, diagnostic studies should be delayed until four to six weeks following the onset of symptoms. Most patients' pain will resolve spontaneously within this time frame. If symptoms and physical findings persist after conservative therapy, diagnostic studies should be obtained. Historically, myelography has been the radiographic study of choice for the diagnosis of a herniated disk. In recent years, CT and MRI have become the primary imaging modalities for this condition. It is known that approximately 35% of symptomatic individuals have evidence of a disk abnormality by myelogram, CT or MRI, with 20% of those under 60 years of age having imaging evidence of a disk herniation. In asymptomatic individuals over 60 years of age, over 50% will have abnormalities. These tests, however, are not without pitfalls or problems in interpretation.
Radiographic Features
Both CT and MRI are excellent techniques to detect and characterize disk herniations. With desiccation and degeneration of the disk, there will be loss of the high intensity signal in the disk on the T2-weighted images. Displacement of nuclear material into the region of the outer annular fibers will cause a focal contour abnormality of the disk. As long as the disk material is contained by the outer annulus or the posterior longitudinal ligament, it is considered a contained herniation. If it penetrates the outer annular-posterior longitudinal ligament complex, it is call a disk extrusion. If the disk material separates from its disk of origin, it is called a sequestered fragment.
Treatment
The mainstay of treatment remains nonoperative. The majority of patients will improve with limited periods of bed rest (three to five days), NSAIDs, patient education and various exercise regimens. Epidural steroids may be of some benefit. A review of the course of symptomatic lumbar disk herniation reveals that surgery plays mainly a palliative role in its management. Results of long-term comparisons of surgical and nonsurgical treatment groups of patients with herniated disks show no statistically significant differences in outcome. Results appear initially better in the surgical group, but this difference diminishes with time. The major benefit of surgical treatment for a herniated lumbar disk appears to be more rapid relief from sciatic pain than is provided by nonsurgical treatment.
Indications for surgical treatment include:
- impairment of bowel or bladder function
- gross motor weakness
- evidence of increasing impairment of nerve root conduction
- severe sciatic pain persisting or increasing despite 4 to 6 weeks of treatment
- recurrent incapacitating episodes of sciatic pain
The acute massive disk herniation that causes bladder and bowel paralysis appears to be best managed by emergent surgical excision. In the face of progressing motor weakness, it is best to intervene early with surgical excision of the disk herniation. It has been shown that patients with a major neurologic deficit eventually made as much recovery with nonsurgical treatment as they did with surgical treatment. However, many surgeons believe that earlier surgery may accelerate neurologic improvement. Failure of nonsurgical treatment is the most common reason for surgical intervention. Optimal nonsurgical treatment occurs over at least four to six weeks, and not more than three to six months. It results in improvement in the patient's symptoms and signs. When incapacitating symptoms continue for more than four to six weeks, are substantiated by appropriate findings (tension signs with or without neurologic deficit), and are verified by collaborative imaging studies (myelogram, CT, MRI), then surgery may be appropriate, depending on the patient's desires and needs.
Surgical Options
The principal goals of surgical intervention are to relieve neural compression and the consequent radiculopathy, while minimizing complications. The most common currently used approach is a limited laminotomy, with disk fragment excision. This surgery yields similar results whether it is performed using standard techniques, loupe magnification or a surgical microscope. More recently, less invasive percutaneous approaches, in which suction, laser or arthroscopic techniques are used, have been advocated.
Limited excision of a herniated disk for relief of sciatica should provide relief of symptoms in more than 90% of properly selected patients. Results of surgery appear to correlate directly with the degree of disk herniation. More than 90% achieve complete relief of sciatica when a free sequestered disk fragment is found at surgery; approximately 80% when an incomplete herniation is present; and 60% to 70% when there is only a protruding disk.
These results emphasize the importance of appropriate patient selection. The relief of back pain as the predominant symptom is unpredictable and usually is not obtained at surgery. When back pain is not a major component of the patient's symptoms before surgery, it can develop postoperatively. Factors leading to surgical failure as a result of back pain include worker's compensation issues, cigarette smoking and age over 40 years.
The most common complication associated with lumbar disk excision are missed pathology, dural tears, and disk-space infection. Some believe these to be more common with the use of the microscope, but many think these problems are related primarily to the surgeon's level of experience or to underlying medical problems.